Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Training at Tata Cancer Hospital, Mumbai

My poor old blog hardly seems worth updating. I would sit down to write something, but someone would interrupt and all thoughts would go flying out.

In March and April, I was lucky enough to go for a two month training to Tata Memorial Hospital, Mumbai for Onco-Pathology training. It scared me initially, because I didn't think my kids would manage without me for a day. But H and my relatives were so supportive that I did go, with tears in my eyes...wishing the flight would get cancelled. But 2 months have passed and now I'm back, and the kids seem to have gotten along fine. God is good, especially to me and mine, I don't know why, but He always is, always have been.



 So when I reached Mumbai, it felt strange, but weirdly, I LOVED it. I loved the way people at Tata worked. They all worked so hard, so diligently. Nobody was looking over their shoulders, but everybody, doctors, nurses, technicians, IV grades, all just went about their work doing their job. I loved the way the hospital was so organized. No reagents in short supply. No power cuts. No unnecessary delays. No corruption apparently, no private practice on the sly (:P) It was work utopia. Their state of the art facilities and equipments make me salivate. And the pathology professors were so good at their jobs, and most of them were so nice! Dr Gujral especially, took some of us (trainees) out for dinner at his own expense.



.

The work ethics of these non-believers humbled me. And I wondered how much I and the other Mizo doctors have to learn, in humility, professionalism and other things. Now don't think I'm bashing my fellow doctors, but the Mizo patients will tell you how nice and approachable most of the vai doctors are to them, while some of us are so rude to our fellow Mizos.

And talking of the Mizo cancer patients, they were living examples of courage and pure grit. I stayed at my allotted hostel in Chembur, but I would always try and spend my weekends at Mizoram House. Our prayer meetings were short but real. No lengthy sermons, but they were speeches from the heart. And you would realize how much people suffer, and yet how much unwavering faith they had in God. It humbled me. I don't know how I would handle having cancer, not as gracefully as any of them, for sure. Staying at Mizoram House was like being in a gospel camp, everybody behaved their best, all goodwill towards everyone else. Although I was initially a little apprehensive about being near the sick patients (I thought they would all be sad and suffering), when I actually stayed with them, they joked about their cancer, their treatment, and all took care of each other. Their sense of humour puts you at ease, and immediately make you feel at home. One point of importance I think is that they all tell me how tired they get at home, with so many well-wishers. Maybe we can learn to give people space and show them we care without tiring them out. Maybe send cards, letters, money, food and not insist on meeting patients face to face when we visit.
Contrary to above paragraph, this patient Actually doesn't mind me visiting!

Thu ka sawi e, te ka ti ve a.

Add caption

A tuarchhel ber, a huai ber.

Infit ber!
For fellow doctors

So actually living with the patients and their relatives made cancer more real, dark and scary. A diagnosis of cancer plunges a person into a dark abyss along with his family, condemning them to a life of chemotherapy, radiation and years and years of check-ups. Being a doctor, our hardwork and/or pure simple luck places us in a terribly vital position. For a pathologist, whether you give the right diagnosis of cancer in a biopsy or FNAC will allow the patient to be treated accordingly. If you say a non-cancerous tumour is cancer, the patient will be subjected to treatment which he doesn't need, and which will eventually probably kill him. If a clinician fails to refer or diagnose a case correctly, the patient will similarly have the same problem. So I think it's important to confer, to discuss with colleagues about our cases, and refer when something is out of our specialty. It is no sign of defeat to consult colleagues in these cases. At Tata, and other hospitals, there would be regular meetings of oncologists, radiologists, pathologists, surgeons, radiotherapists, gynaecologists etc to discuss cases. And these meetings are helpful not only for the patients but also for the doctors. After all, medicine is not something you pass and no longer have to ever study again. We have our textbooks, the world wide web. In difficult cases, I think we should defer giving diagnosis or treatment, till we read and know for sure what we're dealing with. Everyone can make mistakes, but making mistakes because of our egos, ignorance or carelessness is a sin I don't think God will easily forgive.

On the lighter side I also discovered Crawford market, which was a wholesale market with everything at slashed rates. This was a Capricornian haven, because, as Linda Goodman puts it, 'Capricorns like to buy the best things, but at a bargain.' Loved the malls too, but they were mostly just good to hang out at. Crawford market will always stand out as a place where you can get great handbags, toys, prints of famous paintings, most everything, and at a bargain!


I also loved the Elora Caves, or rather the ferry to the Caves. I never knew how much pull the ocean had on me, maybe because I had never seen one before!

So, my trip was a blessing, it taught me a lot academically. I attended conferences (Rs 5000 registration) for free, met many special people, learned lots of new techniques, and refreshed me emotionally. It also reminded me again of how much God takes care of me. For example, while other trainees got roommates who worked in different departments, I got one who was also in Pathology. So I could read her books, use her microscope, etc. I also was always safe everywhere I went, and treated mostly well by the residents and technicians, so I could smuggle back maximum information (I like to think, maybe other trainees feel the same way, haha). I also managed to co-write a scientific paper, for which the HOD assures me I would get first authorship. So yep, that's me, bragging, because things like that don't happen often!






23 comments:

Calliopia said...

Lengthy write-up but so heartfelt throughout. Tata holds special memories for me because I was there with my mother years ago. And I can say that the worst moment in my life ever was when the doctor who had operated on her told me (and my uncle) that she had only 6 months to live. I literally felt like the ground had opened up under my feet right then..

And you’re so right, why are Mizo doctors usually so rude to their patients? They have this really bad tendency to talk to us like stupid, uneducated ignoramuses. The more senior doctors are specially condescending, the younger ones a little more approachable. Perhaps you can spread the word 

Right again on how we look at and treat people with cancer – wait, not just cancer but all sick people in general. We seem to think we can just walk in and visit any time and sit and chat as long as we want. That’s just so annoying. I remember once when my sister was at Civil Hosp., we were once rudely woken up around 6 in the morning by visitors who didn’t seem to realize they were inconveniencing us. The funny thing was the woman actually said, ”In va tawng duh lo em em! :D

Loved your post. Great pics too. You sound like you grew personally and professionally, and that's just wonderful. Kudos to you.

Aduhi Chawngthu said...

Looks like you had a great learning experience. Kei chu doctor te hi ka ngaisang khawp a, I follow every word they say. I haven't had much experience with Mizoram doctors, but I don't think I would keep quiet if I meet the condescending ones. So spread the word, like Calliopia said up there :P

Two months is a long time, and I was just thinking how much you would miss your children!

Nice pics, esp the one with the many boats. I may steal it someday :)

Keep up the good work! Kan damloh hunah min lo vin suh aw!!

diary said...

Calliopia, too much pent-up emotions, I suppose :)

Telling someone how long they have to live is beyond any one's call in my opinion. It's just something nobody should do.

You're right,on the whole, younger doctors seem more approachable. Maybe because there were so few doctors before and were held in such high esteem..I don't know. But of course there are exceptions to the rule, some senior docs are the absolute best!

I can understand how you felt at 6 am. It sometimes seem like the visitors are visiting for themselves, their peace of mind, rather than to genuinely do something good for the patient.

Aduh, yeah, it was a great learning experience. And I really did miss my kids, it's tough for a mom to leave her babies.

Thanks for visiting, and also for leaving your comments :)

Alejendro said...

Oh.. I didn't know that you blog.. :-) worth reading... and hey, you are always welcome in Mumbai :-)

diary said...

Thanks, Alejendro.

Would love to come to Mumbai again!

Mizohican said...

Next time, please come when I am in Mumbai! :) Am still in Delhi, but when I was in Mumbai, I came to the Mizo Church every Sunday and you didn't even turn up once! :D *biru nghal*

Philo said...

Haven't required medical attentiion in Mizoram as yet...but when I do, I hope s/he will have read your introspective piece.

diary said...

Kima, I was in Mumbai when you were in Mumbai! Tak tak a, it's quite an effort to go attend the Mizo service, so I don't blame you. You probably won't miss your seat in heaven because you go to church ;)

diary said...

TheOtherKimaWhoAlwaysGoToChurch, hopefully you would never need a doctor anywhere :) How's life? Aren't you on Facebook btw?

Mizohican said...

That one Friday (Good Friday) when I came back to Mumbai, I REALLY tried to come to the Mizo service just to meet you. Here is my status that day too... CLICK HERE... mahse a lum lutuka, formals in ka in chei bawk sia, ka inthlak leh ringawt a lawm... :(

And I don't think the other Kima is on FB. Only the missus is I think.

diary said...

Kima, ka ti mai mai a nih kha. Keipawh hi ka hrat vak lo. Thla 2 chhung khan vawi 3 vel chiah ka inkhawm. Mahse ka inkhawm hmasak ber kha chu Mumbai Mizo inthlan a nia, Pu Khawlkunga khan ballot paper sem etc velah min tir common nasa khawp mai. lol

Hlua said...

E khai a! I va training hlawhtling ve aw. H te khan in lamah an lo tuar viau na ang a! Thuziak pawh i lo tihmi fu hi, chhiar a nuam emai...

caribou said...

Blogging lampang hi i khawihna a lo va rei tawh bik ve le. I blog lah chu hei, a thain a phusui hle mai.

diary said...

U hlua chu va ti lawmawm ve. Caribou pawh chu. Lo chhiar ve zeuh zeuh ru aw :)

samreen said...

Really I appreciate the effort you made to share the knowledge.
mumbai hospital

We Care India said...

Cancer is a complex set of diseases. Each cancer is unique in the way it grows and develops, its chances of spreading depends on the way it affects one`s body and the symptoms one may experience . Several factors, including location and how the cancerous cells appear under the microscope, determine how cancer is diagnosed. Best Cancer Hospitals in Delhi




manjiT said...

Thats wonderful narration. Contemplating about my specialization after mbbs got me to this post. And if i may say, i was suprised to see one of my college senior now doing residency in tata, in one of your pics. Nice insights into life of a pathologist. May be glimpses of my future.
Thanks :)

diary said...

Hi Manjit..nice of you to drop by and leave a comment. Tata hospital is a good hospital for residency, especially in cancer related things. Great equipments, good working conditions, unlike government hospitals where facilities are just terrible. Wish you all the best :)

RAGGY said...

Hi! Loved the article. Especially the one about Dr. Sumit Gujral. He is a gem of a person. So down to earth and friendly. I am looking forward to my observership there in October.

Unknown said...

very helpful information you have shared..
tata memorial hospital

Unknown said...

Very helpful information. Ur art of writing is very good!

Ak.azmi said...

This is best information, that i read in your post. make more such type of post and infor us thanku.
You can find us at:
Name: Dr. Rajas Patel - Oncologist
Address: Shop. No. 9, New Horizon CHS, Sector 46, Karave Nagar, Seawoods, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra 400706
Appointments: rhoncoclinic.com
Also We provide services Like:
Breast cancer doctor in mumbai
lung cancer specialist in mumbai
Best Medical oncologist in mumbai
Top Cancer Hospital in Mumbai

Anuja Shah said...

Your writing is very impressive. you give a very important info.
thanks for sharing. cancer blog on tumblr